LEEDS UNITED 1 MANCHESTER UNITED 0 – FA Cup Semi Final Replay – The City Ground, Nottingham – Wednesday 31st March 1965

Bremner v Scum

After a brutal semi-final at Hillsborough had ended goalless, the United’s of Leeds and Manchester resumed hostilites at The City Ground, Nottingham four days later.

There was just one change from the 22 players that had started the first game with Terry Cooper coming in for Leeds in place of Albert Johanneson, the South African winger failing to recover from an injury which had left him a passenger in the game at Hillsborough. The BBC once again had coverage with Kenneth Wolstenholme picking up the microphone to describe the action to the Sportsview audience at home.

A much better surface in Nottingham provided conditions for a much better game and both sides went at each other hammer and tongs for 90 minutes. Manchester United had most of the chances, particularly at the start of the second half, but Leeds hung in and got stronger as the game went on. Denis Law had the best chance for the side from the West of the Pennines, bursting clear in the penalty area to shoot from 10 yards but was denied by a fine block by Gary Sprake in the Leeds goal.

With extra time looming, Leeds were awarded a free kick in the centre circle. Johnny Giles lofted the ball forward, deep into the Manchester United box and just when it seemed to be drifting harmlessly through the area, Billy Bremner arrived with his back to goal to somehow get a head on the ball and divert it into the net for the goal that sent the Whites to Wembley for the first time in the clubs history.

There was pandemonium at the final whistle as fans ran on to the pitch and referee Mr Windle, who had been such a controversial  figure in the first game, was knocked over in all the chaos.

So Leeds were on their way to Wembley to meet Liverpool in the final, and were still in pursuit of the League title as well. They would have to face Matt Busby’s men one more time in a match that looked set to be the defining moment in the race for the title.

 

FA Cup Semi Final Replay Wednesday 31st March 1965
LEEDS UNITED 1 MANCHESTER UNITED 0
Coverage by BBC SportsView
Commentator: Kenneth Wolstenholme
LEEDS UNITED (White Shirts, White Shorts) MANCHESTER UNITED (Red Shirts, White Shorts)
1. Gary SPRAKE 1. Pat DUNNE
2. Paul REANEY 2. Shay BRENNAN
3. Willie BELL 3. Tony DUNNE
4. Billy BREMNER 4. Bill FOULKES
5. Jack CHARLTON 5. Paddy CRERAND
6. Norman HUNTER 6. Nobby STILES
7. Johnny GILES 7. George BEST
8. Jim STORRIE 8. Bobby CHARLTON
9. Alan PEACOCK 9. David HERD
10. Bobby COLLONS 10. John CONNELLY
11. Terry COOPER 11. Denis LAW
MANAGER: Don REVIE MANAGER: Matt BUSBY
GOALS
89:00 BREMNER

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

MANCHESTER UNITED 0 LEEDS UNITED 0 – FA Cup Semi Final – Hillsborough 27 March 1965

Featured

1965 fa cup semi final

Leeds United were back on the BBC just a week after beating Everton on Match of the Day but this time were on the main channel as their FA Cup Semi-Final clash with Manchester United was part of BBC 1’s Saturday Night Sports Special.

Kenneth Wolstenholme presented the show but he was at the other semi final between Liverpool and Chelsea at Villa Park with Alan Weeks despatched to Sheffield for this War of the Roses.

And War is a suitable word to describe a brutal match which was the pre-cursor to battles between these two sides over the next few years as the United’s of Leeds and Manchester began a fight for pre-eminence in the English game.

Manchester United had the pedigree at that time and particularly in the FA Cup which they had won on three previous occasions including a 3-1 win over Leicester City just three years before. Leeds on the other hand were contesting the first FA Cup semi-final in the clubs history, but were certainly not overawed by either the opponent or the occasion.

The two sides were placed in 2nd and 3rd in the First Division, and were due to meet in a pivotal clash three weeks later. Leeds had had the upper hand in the first league meeting of the season, winning at Old Trafford in early December so certainly went into the game with nothing to fear from their illustrious opponents.

No footage of the game can be found but if there was any, the highlights would surely be only brief ones. On a churned up Hillsborough pitch, made even worse by overnight rain, the two sides served up a running battle rather than a football match which seemed always destined to finish goalless.

What was more remarkable was that the game ended with 11 players from each side left on the field. From the opening moments when Billy Bremner chopped down Bobby Charlton, earning himself a finger wagging from the Manchester United man, the match was littered with fouls which were allowed to continue throughout thanks to a lenient refereeing display from Mr Windle of Chesterfield who was “in control” of the game.

With the pitch resembling a ploughed field both sides tried to use the wings to create opportunities, but the flair players fared no better and both George Best and Albert Johanneson suffered rough treatment that left them as virtual passengers.

Mr Windle did book Nobby Stiles and Denis Law for challenges that even he considered to be excessive, but remarkably allowed Law to remain on the pitch following the games biggest talking point. The Scotsman reacted to a shirt pull from Jack Charlton by squaring up the Leeds centre half and provoking a bout of fisticuffs which saw players from both sides pile in. Law’s shirt was ripped in the brawl but incredibly no player was booked form either side with Leeds simply being awarded a free kick.

Manchester United had the better of the play but with neither goal seriously threatened, both sides prepared for Round Two at the City Ground the following Wednesday.

FA Cup Semi Final Saturday 27th March 1965
MANCHESTER UNITED 0 LEEDS UNITED 0
Coverage by BBC Sports Special Presented by Kenneth Wolstenholme
Commentator: Alan Weeks
MANCHESTER UNITED (Red Shirts, White Shorts) LEEDS UNITED (White Shirts, White Shorts)
1. Pat DUNNE 1. Gary SPRAKE
2. Shay BRENNAN 2. Paul REANEY
3. Tony DUNNE 3. Willie BELL
4. Bill FOULKES 4. Billy BREMNER
5. Paddy CRERAND 5. Jack CHARLTON
6. Nobby STILES 6. Norman HUNTER
7. George BEST 7. Johnny GILES
8. Bobby CHARLTON 8. Jim STORRIE
9. David HERD 9. Alan PEACOCK
10. John CONNELLY 10. Bobby COLLONS
11. Denis LAW 11. Albert JOHANNESON
MANAGER: Matt BUSBY MANAGER: Don REVIE

Leeds 4 Everton 1 1965

Football League 1st Division Saturday 20th March
LEEDS UNITED 4 EVERTON 1
Coverage by BBC Match of the Day Presented by Kenneth Wolstenholme
Commentator: Kenneth Wolstenholme
LEEDS UNITED (White Shirts, White Shorts) EVERTON (Blue Shirts, White Shorts)
1. Gary SPRAKE 1. Gordon WEST
2. Willie BELL 2. Brian LABONE
3. Terry COOPER 3. Ray WILSON
4. Billy BREMNER 4. Tommy WRIGHT
5. Paul MADELEY 5. Colin HARVEY
6. Norman HUNTER 6. Jimmy GABRIEL
7. Johnny GILES 7. Brian HARRIS
8. Jim STORRIE 8. John MORRISSEY
9. Alan PEACOCK 9. Derek TEMPLE
10. Bobby COLLINS 10. Alex SCOTT
11. Albert JOHANNESON 11. Fred PICKERING
MANAGER: Don REVIE MANAGER: Harry CATTERICK
GOALS
JOHANNESON 1-0
TEMPLE 1-1
BREMNER 2-1
JOHANNESON 3-1
PEACOCK 4-1

After the win over Arsenal, Leeds were unbeaten over their next five games and had progressed through to an FA Cup semi-final. Their last game before facing Manchester United in that semi-final was captured by the Match of the Day cameras as they took on Everton at Elland Road.

The game gave Leeds a chance to go to the top of the first division, with leaders Chelsea having a day off. The Whites were second on just goal average before the game commenced with Kenneth Wolstenholme in the commentary box. Where that commentary box was is unclear, as the game was filmed from the unusual angle of behind one of the goals, at the Kop End of the stadium. I’ve been unable to locate anything other than a 60 second clip taken from “The Glory Years” video produced by the BBC in the late 1980’s.

There were a handful of changes to the Leeds line up from that which had won at Highbury. Paul Reaney and Jack Charlton were missing from the defence, causing a reshuffle which saw Willie Bell move over to right back, Terry Cooper drop back to left back and Paul Madeley slot in seamlessly at centre half. Albert Johanneson came in on the left wing to accomodate Cooper’s move back and up front there was a return for Alan Peacock from injury who replaced Don Weston.

On a heavy pitch it was Leeds that took the lead in the first half. A cross from the left was headed off the post by Jim Storrie but Johanneson was there to knock home the rebound. As for most of the goals on the afternoon, and in line with the BBC commentary of the age, Wolstenholme was very understated in his calls of the goals. “Is it a goal? Yes, scored by Johanneson” greeted the first effort of the afternoon.

Everton were level around the half hour mark as snow began to fall at Elland Road. It was a nice move down Everton’s right which ended with a lovely cross into the box and Derek Temple rising to head home. “That’s a beautiful goal scored by the inside left Temple”

Wolstenholme seemed keen on letting the viewers know in what position each player was playing, sometimes over the player’s name as it was “the right half” who put Leeds back in front before half time as Billy Bremner tucked the ball under Gordon West in the Everton goal.

Leeds added two more in the second half, Johanneson grabbing his second to make it 3-1 with a lovely turn and shot from the corner of the six yard box. Then Peacock made it 4-1 with a lovely glancing finish to a delightful ball in from the right by Johnny Giles.

The result gave Leeds a two point lead at the top of the table, but Chelsea returned to the top with a 3-0 win at Sheffield United the following Monday, maintaining their advantage of goal average. Leeds though were well set for the FA Cup Semi-Final against Manchester United which would take place the following week.

 

CHELSEA 2 LEEDS UNITED 0 – First Division 19th September 1964

Chelsea v Leeds 1964

Football League 1st Division Saturday 19th September 1964
CHELSEA 2 LEEDS UNITED 0
Coverage by BBC Match of the Day Presented by Kenneth Wolstenholme and Danny Blanchflower
Commentator: Kenneth Wolstenholme
CHELSEA (Blue Shirts, Blue Shorts) LEEDS UNITED (White Shirts, White Shorts)
1. Peter BONETTI 1, Gary SPRAKE
2. Ian WATSON 2. Paul REANEY
3. Eddie McCREADIE 3. Willie BELL
4. John HOLLINS 4. Jimmy GREENHOFF
5. Marvin HINTON 5. Jack CHARLTON
6. Ron HARRIS 6. Norman HUNTER
8. George GRAHAM 8. Billy BREMNER
10. Terry VENABLES (Capt) 10. Bobby COLLINS
7. Bert MURRAY 7.Johnny GILES
9. Barry BRIDGES 9. Jim STORRIE
11. Tommy KNOX 11. Albert JOHANNESON
MANAGER: Tommy DOCHERTY MANAGER: Don REVIE
GOALS
VENABLES CHELSEA 1 LEEDS 0
HOLLINS CHELSEA 2 LEEDS 0

 

1964 saw a revolution in British television with the launch of BBC2 in April. The channel was to be home to more serious and diverse programming and to that end they launched a weekly football highlights show to be shown on Saturday evenings after that day’s fixtures. It was to be called Match of the Day, and of course is still going strong some 50 plus years later.

Leeds United’s first appearance on the programme would come on the 19th September 1964. The Whites, newly promoted to the top flight, had made an excellent start to the season and sat in 2nd place in the table before their visit to Stamford Bridge, where they would take on the leaders of the First Division, Chelsea.

Despite the good start to the season, the previous week had been quite a tumultuous one at Elland Road. Disappointed by his latest contract offer, manager Don Revie had applied for the Sunderland job which had been vacant since Alan Brown had departed for Sheffield Wednesday. The Wearside club at the time were a much bigger club than Leeds and had more financial power. It was felt Revie had used the vacancy to increase the offer from Leeds and it worked. Just when it seemed that he was on the brink of walking out on the club, an increased offer of a 5 year contract at £4500 a year was agreed and Revie remained in charge.

He took the side down to London to take on the league leaders who had made an unbeaten start to the season. It was to be the first of many meetings between the two sides over the coming years which would see Chelsea and Leeds become bitter rivals, both on the pitch and on the terraces. Chelsea were managed by Tommy Docherty and he had put together a youthful side, with two future Leeds United managers controlling the midfield, George Graham and Terry Venables.

Leeds lined up with many of the side that had won promotion the following season and was well on the way to becoming a regular line up. Jimmy Greenhoff came into the side for this game at right half, with Billy Bremner pushing further forward. Jim Storrie led the line with support from Johnny Giles and Albert Johanneson.

“What better match could we pick today” said Kenneth Wolstenholme in his introduction to camera, words that would come to haunt him by the end of the programme as the top two sides in the country produced a dull encounter that was more artisan than artistic and did little to counter the reputation of Leeds as a fairly negative and industrious team.

The action started at the pivotal point of the match in the 27th minute, with Eddie McCreadie clattering into Giles in midfield. It was immediately recognized as a bad injury for the Leeds man and a stretcher was called for. So bad was the injury that Don Revie himself came onto the field to check on his man, with Wolstenholme speculating “this looks like it could be a broken leg.”

With no substitutions in those days, Leeds were left to play the remaining hour with just 10 men on a glorious late summer afternoon which would sap energy from the legs. Leeds tried to strike immediately, Bobby Collins firing the free kick given for the challenge on Giles just over the crossbar.

It would take Chelsea just five minutes to make the man advantage count. A ball into the Leeds area was allowed to bounce around and as Bremner hesitated to clear his lines, Venables nipped in to rifle the ball into the roof of the net, prompting Wolstenholme to state it was “a lovely goal.”

Terry Venables 1964

The venerable BBC commentator wasn’t the only voice we could hear, with his microphone occasionally picking up the sound of the crowd sat around him. When referee Bill Clements gave Leeds a free kick for obstruction against Barry Bridges, one punter could quite clearly be heard berating the official with the cry of “You bald headed git. What’s the matter with ya!!”  Unlike today, there were no apologies for any bad language we have heard, the swinging sixties obviously being much more enlightened times.

The Stamford Bridge pitch looked bone hard as the ball was often bouncing around out of control, and was causing problems for players on both sides. Again Leeds failed to cleanly clear a ball bobbling around inside their area allowing Graham to poke the ball towards Venables. The young Chelsea skipper managed to get a shot away but straight at Sprake who fumbled the initial shot and received a whack from a Chelsea player as he dove to gather the loose ball.

Leeds attacks were infrequent, but often featured the pace and skill of Albert Johanneson. Just before the break the Leeds winger intercepted a ball on halfway and raced towards goal, but once he reached the penalty area his composure left him and his effort was a weak cross cum shot that skidded along the ground, too far in front of his team mates and too far wide of the goal to cause Chelsea any great consternation,.

Half time saw some analysis of the first half from recently retired Tottenham and Northern Ireland great Danny Blanchflower. His assessment was that the game was being played between “two well drilled teams giving nothing away” and hoped for a little more in the second half.

He was to be disappointed as the game continued in the same vein with packed defences and two teams seemingly unable to create any real opportunities. Leeds were of course badly hampered by the absence of Giles and as Wolstenholme observed “Chelsea have played eight games and not been beaten by 11 men so Leeds have been given quite a task.” He did report however that Giles had “badly strained knee ligaments and not a break fortunately” something that would perhaps be the reverse these days.

The game was devoid of any real goalmouth action. Leeds had a half chance when Greenhoff over hit a through ball that Peter Bonetti in the Chelsea goal spilled as he slid in to gather. The ball fell straight into the path of Bremner on the right hand side of the area but he rushed his shot and hit it harmlessly wide of the goal. The referee gave a corner and from that, Leeds created an opening for Greenhoff 25 yards out bis his shot was a tame one and rolled straight through to Bonetti.

The Chelsea keeper was tested a little more moments later when Bobby Collins tried his luck from distance and forced him into a sprawling save, but Leeds were being restricted to efforts from distance and the more incisive play was coming from Chelsea. Sprake as worked by a header from Murray after good work on the left from Bobby Knox and the Chelsea left winger had another effort from the corner of the penalty area, hitting a vicious strike straight into the midriff of the Leeds keeper.

With about 15 minutes to go Chelsea doubled their lead and Leeds contributed massively to their own downfall. Uncharacteristically it was the Leeds skipper, Collins, who made the fatal error, miscontrolling the ball on the edge of his own box and allowing the ball to run towards Graham. He poked the ball back to John Hollins and his first time shot seemed to spin off Sprake and trundled into the net. “That was a gift to Chelsea from Bobby Collins” was how Wolstenholme summed up the goal.

Any chances Leeds had of getting back into the game were severely hampered moments later when Greenhoff had to be carried off injured as well, leaving Leeds with just nine men. Although he would return to the field, it was as a a passenger. Chelsea were in complete command and they almost scored a spectacular third when Graham executed a superb scissor kick volley from the edge of the area that whistled just over the bar. It was the best piece of skill in the game and prompted Wolstenholme to “give that the Oscar for this match.”

All that remained was for the niggle, that would become a feature of these games over the coming years, to begin with Ron “Chopper” Harris earning his name by going through Bremner on halfway, quickly followed by the fiery Scot responding in kind moments later with a feet first challenge into the midriff of the Chelsea man.

At the final whistle Wolstenholme and Blanchflower discussed the game. The commentator described it as “Unfortunately not an over exciting game” with Blanchflower concluding that “They are both very young teams and perhaps it was the tension that provided us with such a dull spectacle.” He also concluded that “Johanneson, the coloured boy at outside left is a very exciting player” and that he didn’t think “Leeds are good enough to be at the top, but I think they will have a reasonable season.”

Blanchflower would have thought he had been proved right in the immediate aftermath of this match. Leeds won just one of the next four in the league to drop to 11th in the table, but then caught fire and by the time of their next appearance on television would be in the thick of the title race.